Q1) Representation (Extended Comparison Question - Set Text vs Unseen Text - 30 marks)
The question is likely to ask how an audience is 'positioned'. This means;
- What is the audience's reading of the text? What does it make them think or believe?
- How is this reading encoded in the text and decoded by the audience? How does it make them think or believe that?
In your answer you should:
- Consider how the representations construct versions of reality. What are the representations? Consider the preferred, negotiated & oppositional readings? How are these representations achieved? (constructed through technical codes; camerawork, audio codes, print media codes)
- Consider the similarities and differences in how audiences are positioned by the representations. In what ways are the representations in the two texts similar? In what ways are they different?
- Make judgements and draw conclusions about how far the representations relate to relevant media contexts. Can you link the representations to current issues? News? Debates? Political debates? Stereotypes constructed by the media? Misrepresentations? Myths? Etc
---------------------------------------------------------
Guide to Answering Point 1
- Who or what is being represented? Consider age, gender, ethnicity, job, culture, nationality, financial status, etc.
- What are they doing? Is this activity typical or atypical? Are they conforming to genre expectations or other conventions? Does this form part of a shared conceptual roadmap (Hall)?
- Why are they present? What purpose do they serve? What are they communicating by their presence? What's the preferred reading?
- Where are they? How are they framed? What surrounds them? How does this help to construct meaning for the audience? Does this form part of a shared conceptual roadmap (Hall)?
- How is the representation constructed / audience positioned? Consider use of technical codes associated with moving images, sound & print media.
WHO? WHAT? WHY? WHERE? HOW?
Some Key Terms & Theoretical Frameworks to Consider
- Representation Theory (Stuart Hall)
- Feminist Theory (Van Zoonen)
- Feminist Theory (Bell Hooks)
- Male Gaze Theory (Laura Mulvey)
- Ethnicity & Postcolonial Theory (Paul Gilroy)
- Use of Binary Oppositions (Claude Levi-Strauss)
- Semiotics / Enigma Code (Roland Barthes)
- Denotation & Connotation
- Intertextuality
- Editing (selection / combination): Slow motion, fast motion, colour, monochrome, transition, montage, shot length (short or long)
- Camerawork: Camera distances, movement, angles, framing
- Audio Codes: Diegetic, non-diegetic, synchronous/asynchronous sound, voice-over, underscore
Guide to Answering Point 2
- Common representations? Are these typical genre conventions / stereotypical or not?
- Different representations? Are either of these typical for this genre?
- Are these representations positive or negative?
- Compare how these representations support the various theories (Van Zoonen, Gilroy, etc)
- Are the narratives similar?
- Common use of technical codes to construct similar representations? (editing, camerawork, audio codes)
Some Key Terms & Theoretical Frameworks to Consider
- Typical / Atypical
- Stereotype / Anti-stereotype
- Genre Theory / Repetition & Difference (Steve Neale)
- Supports / Contradicts
- Technical Codes (see key words to Q1 above)
Guide to Answer Point 3
Some key Terms & Theoretical Frameworks to Consider
- Are there any cultural references (through the use of iconic imagery) that are familiar to the audience (help to construct the shared conceptual roadmap or build representations)?
- Could there be a variety of audience responses, depending on where they live, political beliefs, age, gender, etc (different cultural responses)
- Do the texts reflect any political, social, historical religious or economic contexts? Do they link to any current affair / world issues?
Some key Terms & Theoretical Frameworks to Consider
- Iconography / Iconic / Icons
- Shared conceptual roadmap (Hall)
- Culture / Cultural context
- Familiar / Unfamiliar
- Ideology / Beliefs / Argument