19 Mar 2018

Show, Don't Tell Me Assessment Results (Rough Cut) & Teacher Feedback

You can view your assessment results on the SDTM Assessment page (see sidebar) or by clicking here.

The current state of play is;
  1. Talk Back Films (1478 points)
  2. High Society Films (1291 points)
  3. Badass Productions (1026 points)
  4. Prank Productions (952 points)
A first draft of an audio/visual product is called a rough cut. Once you have gathered audience & industry feedback, you should make changes to produce the final cut (as in the Mac software). The final cut is the version of the film that the public see!

You now have 2 hours to read the teacher feedback below and produce your final cut. Final cuts will be teacher assessed only.

Prank Productions
  • Good choice of 'fun time' music at the start (for the moment).
  • Requires sound effects for dice, moving pieces, walking, doors, etc.
  • Watching the two players becomes boring. Would benefit from an insert of one of the pieces being moved or the dice rolling (to break up the single, long duration shot).
  • Massive jump cut at 0:24 that is distracting (needs a clip between them). There is also a significant colour issue at this point (was auto white balance on as I suggested?).
  • Nice, smooth pan at 0:31
  • Could have shown us a POV shot (close-up) of the sign on the door.
  • We can see the reflection of the camera crew in the glass (multiple cases).
  • Accurate match-on-action through the door at the top of the stairs.
  • Change of music at 1:26 is too sudden. I can see what you are trying to do here, but it doesn't quite work...yet.
  • Have we entered the 'crooked house' ride at 1:54? This could be fixed in post production!
  • Nice music becomes a little repetitive.
  • Nice punch effect. Would benefit from an extra shot, showing the reaction to the punch.
  • Title & credits?
  • You didn't include all of the necessary media language (see assessment sheets).

High Society Films
  • Love the dramatic music at the start; supports the zoom in really well.
  • Not sure the zoom out works. Maybe you should cut straight to the opposing player instead.
  • Same for Aaron; zoom in works really well, but not convinced by the zoom out. You've taken the audience into the mind of the players, why take them back out?
  • The zoom in to the game goes on quite a journey - not a straight line. Could be fixed (steadied) in post production in Final Cut (not sure about our software).
  • You use too many zooms; I'm starting to feel travel sick!
  • A fade transition (0:53) is usually used to show the passing of time, but I can see from the game pieces that no time has passed; why not a straight cut then?
  • Change in music could be handled more sensitively.
  • Another unnecessary cross-fade transition at 1:00. And then another straight after. This isn't a wedding video!
  • Another cross-fade to the toilet cutaway...why?
  • Some shaky camerawork which, again, could be fixed in Final Cut.
  • Another cross-fade...STOP IT!
  • And another!
  • And another!
  • And another!
  • Followed by another zoom in and zoom out.
  • All the exam boards state that the biggest mistake candidates make is using too many transition effects and too many zooms; they really hate it when you do that! 95% of all cuts in a 'real' film are straight cuts and you very rarely find any zooms at all.
  • You didn't include all the required media language.

Talk-Back Films
  • Nice, clear titles
  • Lovely, smooth pan of the library to establish the environment. Unfortunately, when you cut to the students at the desk, you're panning in the same direction but at a different speed which gives the impression of a jump cut. Try reversing one of the clips so that is pans from the opposite direction. Is it any better?
  • Perfectly framed two-shot of the main protagonists.
  • Should the moving of pieces be accompanied by sound effects?
  • Great extreme close-ups showing the emotions of the players.
  • Love the added detail (nervously crossing his legs under the table).
  • You break the 180 degree rule many times around here - Dan (?) keeps moving between the left and right - I'm getting disorientated!
  • I think you missed an opportunity to an insert during the game (a close-up of a hand moving a piece on the board).
  • Some interesting camera angles as he goes up the stairs; very creative.
  • Love the added 'letterboxing' effect; adds some drama.
  • Door sound effects?
  • Great insert (POV) of the toilet sign.
  • Love the shot from outside as he runs down the corridor. Whose idea was that? Brings some added interest.
  • Good cross-cutting of narrative. Ah, here is the insert of the board game I wanted!
  • At 1:32, you forgot the 30 degree rule (sometimes called the 45 degree rule). Your camera angle is too similar to the shot before, meaning that it looks like a jump cut (the camera must move by at least 30 degree and, usually, to a different shot distance).
  • Good use of asynchronous sound effect (perhaps a little too loud though).
  • Good shortening of the return journey (ellipsis).
  • Shame that we didn't get any shots of their faces in the final scene to show the audience how they are feeling. Is Dan annoyed, frustrated, laughing...what?
  • Why stop the music before the credits finish? Makes the credits look like a bolt-on or afterthought.

Badass Productions
  • Intriguing opening sequence (make sure your actor doesn't anticipate the action in future - George squints before he is struck!
  • Good use of an intertitle (1 minute earlier).
  • The soundtrack needs addressing; the film would benefit from an appropriate parallel underscore and the use of sound effects (synchronous & asynchronous where appropriate).
  • Excellent cross-cutting between the locations/action.
  • Shot of George 'cheating' lingers a little too long and would benefit from the addition of a wider variety of shot distances & angles. Perhaps a close-up (insert) of his card hand.
  • Good use of zoom & transition to show the passing of time (ellipsis).
  • Fairly accurate match-on-action as Dan returns through the door.
  • Good use of extreme close-ups to show their reactions when Dan returns. Imagine if there was some Western Gunfight music here?
  • Shame that Dan's face is chopped off the 'slap' scene framing - I expect that was due to the lack of room in your chosen location?
  • Good choice of 'victory' music. What would happen if you used slow-motion here as he 'celebrates' his victory?
  • Love the stylish credits at the end.
  • Were all of the required elements included?

Homework

Update your online learning journal. Your SDTM post should include a summary of the brief, your rough cut, your feedback and your final cut.